When it comes to bench sales in the IT staffing industry, one of the most important skills is effectively reaching out to potential clients and vendors to market your bench candidates. Among the various methods of outreach, cold calling and email outreach are the most common—but which one works best? Let's break down the pros and cons of each, so you can decide which method to use based on your goals, audience, and approach.

---

Cold Calling in Bench Sales

Pros:

1. Immediate Engagement: Cold calling provides the opportunity for real-time, direct conversation. You can gauge the client’s reaction, address questions on the spot, and build rapport quickly.
2. Personal Connection: Phone conversations can create a more personal connection than emails. You can use tone, enthusiasm, and empathy to build trust and make a stronger impression.
3. Higher Conversion Rate (When Done Right): A well-crafted cold call can sometimes be more successful than an email, especially if the person on the other end feels an immediate need or connection. You also have the ability to close deals more quickly during a phone conversation.
4. Greater Flexibility: During a call, you can adapt your pitch based on the conversation flow, handle objections in real-time, and tailor the message according to the client's responses.
5. Can Bypass Gatekeepers: Sometimes, getting past gatekeepers (like receptionists or assistants) can be easier through cold calls than emails. You can speak directly to the decision-maker or at least get the opportunity to leave a voicemail or follow-up with an email afterward.

Cons:

1. Time-Consuming: Cold calling takes a significant amount of time. You might need to make numerous attempts before reaching the right person, and many calls may end in rejection or voicemail.
2. Rejection: Cold calling often involves a lot of rejection. People may not be interested or might be annoyed by unsolicited calls, especially if you catch them at a busy time.
3. Not Always Effective for Initial Contact: If you're targeting decision-makers in larger companies, getting through to them via phone can be difficult without a prior introduction or referral.
4. Limited by Time Zones: Unlike email, cold calling is limited to business hours and time zones, which may restrict the window for outreach.

When It Works Best:

• When you want a real-time conversation and an immediate response.
• If you're reaching out to smaller businesses or clients who are more likely to answer their phones.
• When you want to quickly address objections or build a stronger personal rapport.
• When you’ve already made initial contact or have a warm lead and want to follow up with a call.

---

Email Outreach in Bench Sales

Pros:

1. Scalable: Email outreach allows you to contact large numbers of clients or vendors quickly and efficiently. You can craft a message and send it to multiple people at once with minimal effort.
2. Non-Intrusive: Emails can be read at the recipient’s convenience, allowing them to digest your message on their own time. This makes it less likely to come across as an interruption.
3. Trackable: With email, you can easily track whether your message has been opened, whether links were clicked, and how the recipient interacted with the content. This data allows for strategic follow-ups.
4. Easier for Initial Outreach: Emails are often less aggressive and intrusive than cold calls, making them ideal for initial contact with potential clients or vendors who might not be expecting a phone call.
5. Provides a Written Record: Having a written record of your communication can be beneficial for both follow-ups and keeping track of discussions. It’s easier for decision-makers to refer back to an email than a phone call.
6. Can Be Personalized: With the right tools, you can personalize email campaigns to make your outreach feel more relevant and less like a generic message.

Cons:

1. Can Be Ignored or Missed: With so many emails flooding people’s inboxes daily, there's a high chance your email might go unnoticed, land in spam, or get deleted without being opened.
2. Lack of Immediate Interaction: Unlike cold calling, emails lack the real-time engagement and may take longer to get a response, especially if the recipient is busy or away.
3. Difficult to Stand Out: In a crowded inbox, your email may get lost unless it’s carefully crafted to stand out. You need a compelling subject line, clear value proposition, and a well-designed body text to grab attention.
4. Can Be Seen as Impersonal: While emails can be personalized, they still lack the warmth and personal touch of a phone call. Some recipients may view an email as less genuine or less likely to lead to a meaningful conversation.

When It Works Best:

• When reaching out to a large volume of potential clients or vendors.
• If you’re working with decision-makers who are difficult to reach by phone or often busy.
• When you need to follow up on a previous conversation or provide detailed information (like candidate profiles or project proposals).
• If your approach is data-driven and you want to track the results of your outreach.
• When you're targeting larger companies with structured processes for vetting vendors.

---

Which One Works Best?

It Depends on Your Strategy: Both cold calling and email outreach have their place in the bench sales process, and the most successful strategy often involves a combination of both.

Here’s how you can combine them for the most effective results:

• Start with Email Outreach: Use email to make the first connection, especially if you’re contacting a large number of potential clients or vendors. You can introduce your services, explain the value your bench candidates bring, and include links or documents for more information.
• Follow Up with Cold Calling: After a few days, follow up with a cold call to those who opened the email. This allows you to engage with the prospect more directly, answer any questions, and move toward a closer relationship or a sale.
• Use Cold Calls for Warm Leads: If you’ve already had some interaction with a client or vendor (perhaps through email or a previous conversation), cold calling is a great way to follow up and close the deal.
• Email for Mass Outreach, Call for Personalization: Use email for outreach at scale but save phone calls for high-value, personalized interactions, where you want to have a more meaningful conversation and potentially close a deal.

---

Best Practices for Both Methods

• For Cold Calling:
  • Have a clear script but remain flexible in your approach.
  • Focus on building rapport quickly.
  • Respect gatekeepers: If you can’t get through to the decision-maker, be polite and ask for a better time to call or leave a message.
• For Email Outreach:
  • Keep your subject line short, compelling, and relevant.
  • Focus on a strong value proposition—what benefit does your candidate bring to the client?
  • Include a clear call to action (e.g., schedule a call, request a meeting).

---

Conclusion

Both cold calling and email outreach have their merits in bench sales, and each method works best in different contexts. Email outreach is excellent for initial contact, bulk outreach, and providing a detailed pitch, while cold calling is powerful for real-time engagement, relationship building, and quicker conversions.

The most effective strategy is usually a blend of both methods: use emails for initial contact and follow-ups, and cold calling for deeper, more personalized outreach when you need to build trust and close deals quickly.